Bullying is a serious problem that anyone can potentially experience in school life.
It is said that bullying perpetrators and victims each have distinctive personality traits.
Recent research suggests that three personality traits called the “Dark Triad” show connections to bullying.
The paper “Dark Triad Personality Traits as Predictors of Bullying and Victimization in Adolescents” revealed how the Dark Triad is involved in bullying perpetration behaviors and victimization experiences.
This article provides detailed explanations of Dark Triad traits and explores key points for considering bullying issues.
We hope high school students will find hints for understanding their own and others’ personalities and creating a school life free from bullying.
Let’s think about bullying issues together.
Once again, personality researcher and author of Villain Encyclopedia, Tokiwa (@etokiwa999), will provide the explanation.
※We have developed the HEXACO-JP Personality Assessment! It has more scientific basis than MBTI. Tap below for details.
目次
The Relationship Between Bullying and Personality
Characteristics of Bullying Perpetrators and Victims
It is known that perpetrators and victims each have distinctive personality traits.
Bullying perpetrators tend to have strong desires to dominate others and lack empathy.
On the other hand, bullying victims tend to have low self-esteem and be introverted with poor social skills.
Additionally, it is believed that family environment and social status also influence both bullying perpetrators and victims.
Understanding the characteristics of bullying perpetrators and victims helps with bullying prevention and countermeasures.
It is necessary to look at not only individual personality but also environmental factors.
When addressing bullying issues, it is important to consider the personalities of both perpetrators and victims.
How Personality Affects Bullying
Personality has a significant impact on bullying perpetration behaviors and victimization experiences.
People with specific personality traits tend to be more likely to be involved in bullying.
For example, highly aggressive people are more likely to become bullying perpetrators, while people who struggle with self-assertion are more likely to become bullying victims.
It is also known that the combination of personality traits affects how people become involved in bullying.
- People with high self-esteem and low empathy are more likely to become bullying perpetrators
- People with low self-esteem and poor social skills are more likely to become bullying victims
By understanding the relationship between personality and bullying, we can predict bullying risks and take early countermeasures.
When addressing bullying issues, it is important to take individual personality traits into consideration.
What is the Dark Triad
The Dark Triad refers to a combination of three personality traits: Machiavellianism, narcissism, and psychopathy.
These traits are known to be associated with socially undesirable behaviors.
People with Dark Triad traits tend to manipulate others and act self-centeredly.
They also have characteristics of lacking empathy and being less likely to feel guilt.
The Dark Triad has been pointed out to be related to bullying perpetration behaviors.
- Machiavellianism: The tendency to manipulate others and use them for one’s own purposes
- Narcissism: The tendency to have strong self-love and seek admiration from others
- Psychopathy: The tendency to lack empathy and engage in impulsive, antisocial behaviors
The concept of the Dark Triad provides an important perspective for understanding bullying issues.
Early identification of people with these traits and providing appropriate support is required.
The Connection Between Machiavellianism and Bullying
Definition and Characteristics of Machiavellianism
It refers to the tendency to manipulate others and use them for one’s own purposes.
People high in Machiavellianism act strategically and skillfully exploit others’ weaknesses.
They also have characteristics of lacking empathy and being less likely to feel guilt.
Machiavellianism is associated with the following behavioral characteristics.
- Manipulating others and using them for one’s own purposes
- Acting strategically and trying to achieve long-term goals
- Not showing emotions outwardly and calmly judging situations
Machiavellianism can cause problems in interpersonal relationships.
Because they do not respect others and act for their own benefit, friction with those around them tends to arise.
The Impact of Machiavellianism on Bullying Perpetrator Behavior
People high in Machiavellianism have been found to tend to engage in bullying perpetrator behavior.
The characteristics of manipulation of others and strategic behavior are thought to lead to bullying perpetrator behavior.
People high in Machiavellianism identify others’ weaknesses and use them to engage in bullying.
They also involve those around them to promote bullying in order to achieve their own objectives.
The impact of Machiavellianism on bullying perpetrator behavior can be summarized as follows.
- Using others’ weaknesses to engage in bullying
- Involving those around them to promote bullying in order to achieve their own objectives
- Being less likely to feel guilt, making it easier to continue bullying
People high in Machiavellianism can be said to have a high risk of becoming bullying perpetrators.
Therefore, it is important to discover Machiavellian characteristics early and provide appropriate guidance.
Behavioral Patterns of People with Machiavellianism
People high in Machiavellianism exhibit characteristic behavioral patterns.
They manipulate others and use those around them to achieve their own objectives.
They are also skilled at situational judgment and can act strategically.
The behavioral patterns of people with Machiavellianism can be summarized as follows.
- Identifying others’ weaknesses and using them
- Not showing their own emotions and acting calmly
- Acting strategically to achieve long-term goals
- Not respecting others and prioritizing their own interests
These behavioral patterns can cause problems in interpersonal relationships.
They may not be trusted by those around them and could become isolated.
Understanding the behavior of people with Machiavellianism leads to appropriate responses to them.
It is required to identify behavioral patterns and provide necessary support.
The Relationship Between Machiavellianism and Bullying Victimization
People high in Machiavellianism tend to be less likely to become bullying victims.
The characteristics of this trait, strategic behavior and manipulation of others, are thought to lead to the power to avoid bullying victimization.
People high in Machiavellianism can assess surrounding situations and maneuver skillfully.
They also use others’ weaknesses and try to establish their own position.
The relationship between Machiavellianism and bullying victimization can be summarized as follows.
- Assessing surrounding situations and avoiding bullying
- Manipulating others and establishing their own position
- Not showing emotions and dealing with situations calmly
However, the possibility of people high in Machiavellianism experiencing bullying victimization is not zero.
Depending on the situation, they too can become targets of bullying.
Understanding the relationship between Machiavellianism and bullying victimization will help in viewing bullying problems from multiple angles.
Knowing the characteristics of bullying victims leads to appropriate support.
The Relationship Between Narcissism and Bullying
Definition and Characteristics of Narcissism
Refers to the tendency to have extremely strong self-love and consider oneself a special existence.
People high in narcissism have confidence in their abilities and appearance and seek praise from others.
They also have characteristics of poor empathy for others and hypersensitive reactions to criticism.
Narcissism is associated with the following behavioral characteristics.
- Considering themselves a special existence and believing they are superior to others
- Seeking praise and admiration, showing off their achievements
- Poor empathy for others, unable to understand others’ feelings
- Hypersensitive reactions to criticism, easily hurt self-esteem
When narcissism is too high, problems can arise in interpersonal relationships.
Self-centered behavior creates friction with those around them and can lead to isolation.
The Impact of Narcissism on Bullying Victimization Experiences
People with high narcissism tend to be more likely to become victims of bullying.
The characteristics of this personality, such as strong self-love and lack of empathy toward others, are thought to lead to bullying victimization.
People with high narcissism consider themselves special beings and seek admiration from others.
Therefore, they are sensitive to reactions from those around them and react excessively to criticism.
The impact of narcissism on bullying victimization experiences can be summarized as follows.
- Due to strong self-love, they react hypersensitively to criticism and are easily hurt
- Due to low empathy toward others, they are more likely to become targets of bullying
- Behaviors seeking admiration may instead invite bullying
People with high narcissism can be said to have a high risk of becoming bullying victims.
Understanding their characteristics and providing appropriate support is required.
Behavioral Patterns of People with Narcissism
People with high narcissism exhibit characteristic behavioral patterns.
They consider themselves special beings and seek admiration from others.
They also have characteristics of poor empathy toward others and hypersensitive reactions to criticism.
The behavioral patterns of people with narcissism can be summarized as follows.
- Show off their abilities and achievements, seeking admiration
- Act self-centeredly without understanding others’ feelings
- React excessively to criticism and have easily hurt self-esteem
- Look down on others and try to feel superior
These behavioral patterns can cause problems in interpersonal relationships.
They may also face resentment from those around them and become isolated.
Understanding the behavior of people with narcissism leads to appropriate responses to them.
Identifying behavioral patterns and providing necessary support is required.
The Relationship Between Narcissism and Bullying Perpetration
People with high narcissism may also become bullying perpetrators.
The characteristics of this personality, such as superiority complex and lack of empathy toward others, are thought to lead to bullying perpetration behavior.
People with high narcissism consider themselves special beings and tend to look down on others.
They also may act self-centeredly without understanding others’ feelings.
The relationship between narcissism and bullying perpetration can be summarized as follows.
- Look down on others from a sense of superiority and make them targets of bullying
- Due to low empathy toward others, they don’t consider the impact of bullying
- When their self-love is threatened, they may become aggressive
However, not all people with high narcissism become bullying perpetrators.
There are individual differences, and it also changes depending on the situation.
Understanding the relationship between narcissism and bullying perpetration will be an important perspective in considering measures against bullying problems.
By knowing the characteristics of bullying perpetrators, we can find appropriate intervention methods.
The Relationship Between Psychopathy and Bullying
Definition and Characteristics of Psychopathy
Refers to the tendency for emotions and conscience to be lacking and to engage in antisocial behavior.
People with high psychopathy have characteristics of low empathy toward others and difficulty feeling guilt.
They also often engage in impulsive and aggressive behavior and tend to ignore social norms.
Psychopathy is associated with the following behavioral characteristics.
- Low empathy toward others and inability to understand others’ feelings
- Difficulty feeling guilt and justifying their own actions
- Engaging in impulsive and aggressive behavior and ignoring social norms
- Appear attractive on the surface but are cold and calculating inside
When psychopathy is too high, there is also a danger that it may lead to serious criminal acts.
It will be a major barrier to living a social life.
The Impact of Psychopathy on Bullying Perpetration
People with high psychopathy have been shown to have a strong tendency to become bullying perpetrators.
The lack of empathy and aggression that characterizes this personality type is thought to lead to bullying perpetration.
People with high psychopathy do not understand others’ feelings and are less likely to feel guilt, so they engage in bullying without hesitation.
Additionally, their impulsive and aggressive nature becomes a cause for escalating bullying.
The impact of psychopathy on bullying perpetration can be summarized as follows.
- Due to low empathy toward others, they do not consider the impact of bullying
- Due to difficulty feeling guilt, they continue bullying
- Due to high aggression, bullying tends to escalate easily
People with high psychopathy can be said to have an extremely high risk of becoming bullying perpetrators.
Early detection and appropriate intervention are important issues that need to be addressed.
Behavioral Patterns of People with Psychopathy
People with high psychopathy exhibit characteristic behavioral patterns.
They are characterized by low empathy toward others and difficulty feeling guilt.
They also often engage in impulsive and aggressive behavior and tend to ignore social norms.
The behavioral patterns of people with psychopathy can be summarized as follows.
- They do not consider others’ feelings and prioritize their own desires
- They do not feel guilt and justify their actions
- They act impulsively and become irritable and aggressive
- They are superficially charming but internally cold and calculating
These behavioral patterns cause significant problems in interpersonal relationships.
They are likely to be feared by those around them and become isolated.
Understanding the behavior of people with psychopathy leads to appropriate responses to them.
It may be necessary to identify behavioral patterns and provide support from specialists.
The Relationship Between Psychopathy and Bullying Victimization
People with high psychopathy tend to be less likely to become bullying victims.
The coldness and aggression that characterize this personality type are thought to contribute to their ability to avoid bullying victimization.
People with high psychopathy do not care about others’ emotions and prioritize their own interests.
Also, their aggressive attitude in confronting those around them makes them less likely to become targets of bullying.
The relationship between psychopathy and bullying victimization can be summarized as follows.
- They do not care about others’ emotions and are less affected by bullying
- They confront those around them with an aggressive attitude and avoid bullying
- They avoid becoming targets of bullying through superficial charm
However, this does not mean that people with high psychopathy never experience bullying victimization.
Depending on the situation, they may also become targets of bullying.
Understanding the relationship between psychopathy and bullying victimization will help us view bullying issues from multiple perspectives.
Understanding the characteristics of bullying victims is important for considering appropriate support measures.
About Gender Differences
The Relationship Between Dark Triad and Bullying in Boys
Boys have been found to have a strong relationship between Dark Triad traits and bullying perpetration.
In particular, Machiavellianism and psychopathy are thought to influence bullying perpetration in boys.
Boys have a strong tendency to care about their status within their peer groups and try to elevate their status by manipulating others or engaging in aggressive behavior.
The relationship between the Dark Triad and bullying in boys can be summarized as follows.
- Boys with high Machiavellianism engage in bullying by manipulating others
- Boys with high psychopathy engage in bullying through aggressive behavior
- Narcissism does not significantly influence bullying perpetration in boys
When considering bullying issues in boys, it is important to understand Dark Triad traits.
In particular, measures against Machiavellianism and psychopathy will be required.
It is important to consider effective approaches based on the relationship between the Dark Triad and bullying in boys.
The Relationship Between Dark Triad and Bullying in Girls
Girls have been found to have a strong relationship between Dark Triad traits and bullying victimization experiences.
In particular, girls with high narcissism are thought to be more likely to become targets of bullying.
Girls tend to place greater importance on interpersonal relationships, and when their self-esteem is threatened, they are prone to being deeply hurt.
The relationship between the Dark Triad and bullying among girls can be summarized as follows:
- Girls with high narcissism are more likely to become targets of bullying
- Machiavellianism and psychopathy do not significantly affect girls’ experiences of being bullied
- Dark Triad traits also influence girls’ bullying perpetration behavior to some extent
When considering the issue of bullying among girls, understanding narcissism becomes particularly important.
Early detection of girls with high narcissism and providing appropriate support will be required.
Based on the relationship between the Dark Triad and bullying among girls, it is important to consider detailed responses.
Why the Impact on Bullying Differs Between Males and Females
Why does the influence of the Dark Triad on bullying differ between males and females?
The reasons for this are thought to include differences in gender roles and interpersonal relationship styles between males and females.
Males tend to place greater importance on status within their peer group and try to elevate their position through aggressive behavior.
On the other hand, females tend to place greater importance on interpersonal relationships and are prone to being deeply hurt when their self-esteem is threatened.
The reasons why the impact on bullying differs between males and females can be summarized as follows:
- Males place importance on status and are prone to aggressive behavior
- Females place importance on interpersonal relationships and are easily hurt when their self-esteem is threatened
- Differences in social gender roles lead to differences in the impact on bullying
Understanding the differences in bullying between males and females is an important perspective when considering effective approaches.
Detailed responses according to gender will be required.
Based on the reasons why the impact on bullying differs between males and females, it is important to provide appropriate support for each.
Measures for Bullying Prevention
Early Detection of Students with Dark Triad Traits
Early detection of students with Dark Triad traits is important for bullying prevention.
Teachers and counselors should pay attention to students’ behavior and words, and not overlook signs of the Dark Triad.
Key points for early detection of students with Dark Triad traits are as follows:
- Focus on students who manipulate others or engage in aggressive behavior
- Focus on students with strong narcissism and poor empathy for others
- Focus on students who are superficially charming but inwardly cold
- Be sensitive to changes in students’ behavior and words
For early detection, it is important for teachers and counselors to communicate with students and build trusting relationships.
Listening to students’ concerns and providing appropriate support will be required.
Early detection of students with Dark Triad traits and appropriate intervention leads to bullying prevention.
The Role of School Counselors
School counselors play an important role in bullying prevention.
Counselors professionally address students’ psychological issues and provide appropriate support.
They are required to understand Dark Triad traits related to bullying and work on early detection and intervention.
The role of school counselors can be summarized as follows:
- Professionally address students’ psychological issues
- Understand Dark Triad traits and work on early detection and intervention
- Build trusting relationships with students, parents, and teachers
- Support the planning and implementation of school-wide bullying prevention measures
It is important for counselors to collaborate not only with students but also with parents and teachers, working on bullying issues school-wide.
They are expected to propose effective approaches by utilizing their professional knowledge and experience.
The presence of school counselors is indispensable for bullying prevention.
They will be required to support each individual student and provide appropriate assistance.
Development of Effective Intervention Methods
It is important to develop effective intervention methods for students with Dark Triad traits.
Conventional bullying prevention measures may not be sufficiently effective in some cases.
Special intervention methods that consider Dark Triad traits are needed.
Key points for developing effective intervention methods are as follows:
- Understand Dark Triad traits and consider individual approaches
- Approach students with empathy without damaging their self-esteem
- Present specific methods to promote behavioral change in students
- Maintain a long-term perspective and provide continuous support
The development of intervention methods requires the cooperation of teachers, counselors, researchers, and others.
It will be necessary to gather professional knowledge and create evidence-based approaches.
Developing and implementing effective intervention methods will lead to support for students with Dark Triad characteristics.
Providing approaches tailored to each individual student will be the key to bullying prevention.
The Importance of Education for Students and Parents
Education for students and parents is essential for bullying prevention.
It is important to deepen understanding of Dark Triad characteristics and provide opportunities to think about bullying issues.
Schools should actively conduct awareness activities for students and parents.
The importance of education for students and parents can be summarized as follows.
- Deepen understanding of Dark Triad characteristics
- Provide opportunities to think about bullying issues
- Raise awareness among students and parents and encourage cooperation in bullying prevention
- Schools and families collaborate to work together on bullying issues
In educational activities, it is important to explain in easy-to-understand language and include specific examples.
An approach that enables students and parents to think and act independently will be required.
Education for students and parents forms the foundation of bullying prevention.
Greater effects can be expected when schools and families work together as one.
The bullying problem is an issue that should be addressed not only by schools but by society as a whole.
It is important to aim for a society without bullying through education for students and parents.
In Conclusion
The bullying problem is a serious issue that anyone may face in school life.
It has become clear that three personality traits called the Dark Triad influence both perpetrator behavior and victim experiences.
Understanding the traits of Machiavellianism, narcissism, and psychopathy will be an important perspective when considering bullying issues.
However, solving this problem requires not only individual traits but also efforts from schools and society as a whole.
A multifaceted approach is required, including education for students and parents, utilization of school counselors, and development of effective intervention methods.
I hope that high school students will understand their own and others’ personalities and not miss signs of bullying.
And when bullying is discovered, it is important to act with courage.
Each individual thinking and acting independently leads to schools without bullying and a society without bullying.
Writer & Supervisor: Eisuke Tokiwa
Personality Psychology Researcher / CEO, SUNBLAZE Inc.
As a child he experienced poverty, domestic abuse, bullying, truancy and dropping out of school — first-hand exposure to a range of social problems. He spent 10 years researching these issues and published Encyclopedia of Villains through Jiyukokuminsha. Since then he has independently researched the determinants of social problems and antisocial behavior (work, education, health, personality, genetics, region, etc.) and has published 2 peer-reviewed journal articles (Frontiers in Psychology, IEEE Access). His goal is to predict the occurrence of social problems. Spiky profile (WAIS-IV).
Expertise: Personality Psychology / Big Five / HEXACO / MBTI / Prediction of Social Problems
Researcher profiles: ORCID / Google Scholar / ResearchGate
Social & Books: X (@etokiwa999) / note / Amazon Author Page